The cage was still in the living room but not sure if they still had the hamster - either way hair could have been in the floor. She was found next to the couch on her side, and evidence suggested that she had been moved from a lewd position. Jamies remark about the back door being left open was also taken into account. He also told the police that Marty was a friend of Plumas County Sheriff Doug Thomas and that Marty once let Thomas live with him. But how could the caller have known that based on the skull alone? On the third anniversary of the murders, the skull was found about 50 miles away in a whole other county. Just after the finding had been publicly announced, the Butte County Sheriffs Office received an unidentified call that told them they had just discovered the remains of Tina Sharp. The Department of Justice administered a polygraph to Marty Smartt on April 17, which he is said to have passed. His arms were resting on his abdomen with his wrists tightly wrapped in white cloth medical tape. The body is cold. There was a bent steak knife on the ground plus a claw hammer and butcher knife, both covered in blood, on a table in the entryway. Three of which were found dead inside Cabin 28. This involvement couldve been with the murders themselves and the subsequent cover-up. On April 22, 1984, three years and eleven days after the killings, a bottle collector fumbled across what seemed to be bones. It begs the question of how the sheriffs office chose to go with an amateur volunteer when they had the Department of Justices skilled artists at their disposal? What inDana's autopsy leads you to believe he had a black eye and busted lip that was several hours old before he was killed? Others may look at it more accusingly. Glenna Sue Sharp had gotten married in Connecticut and raised five children there: John (15), Sheila (14), Tina (12), Rick (10), and Greg (5). That is until Gamberg and Hagwoods involvement in the investigation. The Plumas County Sheriffs Office handled the initial investigation into the quadruple homicide. . Forensics, however, suggested that more than one claw hammer was used during the killing. This strip of medical tape was found near Sue Sharps body and was one of the few items recovered from the scene that had DNA on it that could be tested for. Dana got hit with a hammer by the brown-haired man while trying to escape out of the back, and John was attacked by the black-haired man. Crim and Bradley never questioned him further on this either. On the morning of April 11 1981 14-year-old Sheila Sharp returned from a neighbors house after a sleepover and stumbled upon the most disturbing and gruesome scene that she and the rest of Keddie California had ever seen. Hold Plumas County Sheriff's Office accountable!". Whilst the inquiry into the murders was taking place, the FBI was examining the disappearance of Tina. Arriving officers refused to listen to Justin even after he told the sheriff's office Tina was taken from her bed on the night of the murders. What else do you want!, The letter was disregarded by the police and not acknowledged as evidence. In April 2018, Gamberg stated that they had managed to regain DNA from a single piece of medical tape at the crime scene and that the DNA positively fitted that of a known living suspect. Great. Nonetheless, after they couldnt discover her, they began looking at her as a possible kidnapping. I dont put anything outside the realm of possibility.. Dana had a different kind of much wider medical tape around his wrists and ankles. Sheila was asked if Johnny had a gun but she did not know (no indication from our reports if Ricky was ever asked). . This murder is shrouded in mystery, leaving behind a messy and compelling trail of clues. The audio of that 911 call is now being compared with audio of suspects, looking for a match. The father of Dana Wingate, the friend of the Sharps that was also killed, said in 2001 that the police had stumbled over each other and fouled up the case and he isnt alone in that line of thinking. During the interview with Bo, Detective Crim mentioned that Bo was a retired police officer something he never was. But for veteran crime writer and crusading editor J. Patrick OConnor, the factsor a lack of themdidnt add up. In 1980, Sue moved her kids to the Keddie area, where they lived in relative poverty. The sheriff's office did not properly secure the scene and failing to call the Department of Justice immediately upon arriving. Isthe woundon the autopsy reports? In addition to their rocky start with evidence, Hagwood and Gamberg discovered that the initial investigation had procured a good number of leads. A GRAPHIC Look Back at the Keddie Murders Photo Archive A GRAPHIC Look Back at the Keddie Murders On the morning of April 11, 1981, 14-year-old Sheila Sharp returned from a neighbor's house after a sleepover and stumbled upon the most disturbing and gruesome scene that she and the rest of Keddie, California, had ever seen. On April 12, 1981, in Keddie, California, the Sharp family and some friends went to sleep in cabin 28 in the Keddie Resort Lodge. Privacy Policy. Examination of the skull showed Tina was likely killed the night or soon after she was kidnapped. Keddie murders revisited part 1: New evidence discovered links living suspect to grisly scene - Plumas News The Sharp family's home shortly after the infamous murders took place in 1981. The sheriffs department also will not accept assistance from other law enforcement agencies. Their biggest motivation was to provide the living family members with answers. Nobody ever said Sheila was stupid. I've been reworking Timeline Z and, in doing so, revisiting all the documents on hand. Furthermore, after three decades nothing has been done with the bloody fingerprint that was collected from the scene. A fact that well touch on later. Posted in CAUTION, CRIME SCENE PHOTOS, Controversial, Deadly History, Did You Know, Disturbing Images, Family annihilators, Family Murders, Historical Events, Killer Moms, Outrageous Crimes, Parents Who Kill, Suicide, Tragic Deaths, true crime, Women Who Kill 2 Comments on The Death Of The Goebbels & Their Children Update On Child Killer Eric Smith Despite all this, everyone enjoyed themselves. By the 1980s, the owner of the resort, Gary Mollath, had no option but to rent his cabins to mostly low-income families. About the Cabin 28 Keddie Murders Case: The morning of April 12, 1981, Glenna Sue Sharp and her kids, Tina and John, and John's friend, Dana Wingate, were brutally murdered inside house #28 in Keddie, California. The hammer was similar to the one that Martin claimed to have lost almost 35 years prior. They left the bar fairly quickly as Martin hated the music they were playing there and was adamantly complaining about it. If you were to ask most people, they would probably say they have never heard of Keddie, the small town in Plumas County, California. Updated 2/11/2020 - Sue Sharp, her son John and his friend Dana were found in the Sharp family cabin beaten and strangled to death in the family room. Until Hagwood and Gamberg took over, any efforts to solve the case were foiled by the overwhelming lack of traceable DNA or fingerprints left at the crime scene. While he saw the men tying up the boys ankles, Justin claimed he hid behind the door right when Tina Sharp entered the living room as the black-haired man stabbed Sue Sharp. Martin had a reputation for being obsessed with the Bible and lecturing people whom he considered immoral. A mother, two of her children, and one of her childs friends were all found dead in their home. Also note how close the cabin is to its neighbor. A mother, two of her children, and one of her child's friends were all found dead in their home. Keddie Cabin 28 Crime Scene Photos. Blood was discovered on Tinas bed, knife marks were found on multiple walls around the house, a bloody fingerprint was discovered inside a door frame and on a railing, and a footprint was discovered at the back of the home. They all performed their normal activities through the day until it reached night-time. Dana's Autopsy Report by kmik Feb 22, 2022 4:27:11 GMT: Interviews & Statements. This call was recorded, per protocol, and copied onto a tape. Keddie is a small town in the mountains of Northern California, about 87 miles from Reno, Nevada. Today, Keddie is little more than a derelict ghost town. About the Case. Bo returned to Chicago, where he died in 1988. When they got home, Marilyn (Martins wife) decided to go to bed at 11:00 pm. Hancock believes that the Plumas County Sherriff's Office did careless work regarding the investigation of the crime. She shared her feelings about the case and suggested that Martin Smartt and John Bo Boubede were to blame. 28 of the Keddie Resort. The therapist had then shared Martins confession with law enforcement, but that confession was never used against Martin, nor did the therapist hear about any follow-up. Click here to remove banner ads from this forum. Sue was found semi-wearing a robe with her airways blocked with her own underwear and a bandana. The sheriffs office spoke to Martin Smartt, Justin Easons stepfather. It is known that Bo, Marty and Marilyn stopped by Sues cabin on their way to the local bar earlier in the evening. Please Login or Register. Sheriff Hagwood and SI Gamberg started by reviewing what had already been collected and done during the initial investigation. CABIN 28: THE KEDDIE MURDERS is unlike any other true crime book on the market today. Strange feelings about the Keddie Murders - a report. in Brownsville and all three remain About Unsolved 1960s Murders . This was what Sheriff Hagwood and SI Gamberg had to work with. During his 1981 interview, Martin Smartt had mentioned that he had lost a claw hammer, similar to the murder weapon found at the crime scene. Here it is, I'd never noticed it before, I was wondering if the hair possibly have been Tinas, The Keddie Murders | Methodical Breakdown | A Real Cold Case Detective's Opinion, Harlan Embrey, Composite Sketch Artist, Known Statements from Persons of Note, Crime Scene Investigation and Evidence Collection, Items Recovered from the Dumpster at General Store, Corruption & PCSO (+DOJ, FBI, ME, etc. John perished from knife wounds and blunt-force trauma. Cold Case Friday: The Mysterious Vanishing of the James Whitey Bulger Bostons Most Infamous Mobster. Marty, his wife Marilyn and her two sons (one of the boys being Justin) lived in Cabin 26 just down the road from Cabin 28. This time around, Justin claimed that a loud noise startled him awake and that he peered through the door to see what was going on. There are people locally who know more than theyve said and I believe weve identified some of them and we know who they are, and we know where they are, and I have every confidence that they either participated after the fact, or they have first-hand information. Its worth mentioning that Hagwood said that there are at least six of these people of interest, all of which are alive. But said that the two were not friends to her knowledge. Brenda Gerow (21), was found murdered in early April 1981 in Tucson, Arizona. Her throat had also been stabbed horizontally, with the knife going through her neck, into her larynx, and nicking her spine. After the murders, Martin told police he was missing a hammer and claimed he didn't know what had happened to it. The initial police investigation went cold and has remained a mystery for about 40 years. Heres one final thought from Sheriff Hagwood. Sue Sharp was the only one covered with a blanket. That is until 2002 when a filmmaker Josh Hancock took on the challenge of making a documentary about what happened in the small town of Keddie. Unfortunately, the murders of four people shocked the residents of Keddie and changed all of that in a matter of hours. It has brought to light some amazing timelines, histories, and what some may call coincidence. Sues younger sons, Rick and Greg, and their 12-year-old friend Justin Eason were also in the house but hadnt been physically harmed. Investigation Police arrived at around 8:00 am and began their investigation of the murders. They rented a 1-bedroom trailer located at the Claremont Trailer Village in Quincy that Don and his wife recently vacated. What else do you want? Marilyn doesnt recall receiving the letter. Nonetheless, when under the impact of hypnosis, Justin was able to give a detailed, concise, and very logical description of the events that he is thought to have witnessed. Furthermore, how could the children in the house sleep when three people were being brutally tortured and murdered right in the next room? At the start of the interview, Bo indicated he knew which one of the cabins was the one where the murders were committed, but toward the middle of the interview, he said he did not know. Made up of log cabins, the town was an ideal place to raise a family. They got many things wrong and many things right in the report. She also mentioned Marty had a violent temper and often abused her, both emotionally and physically. For reasons unknown, Bo lied and said Marilyn was his niece when, in fact, they are not related in any manner. JOHNNY SHARP AUTOPSY. What may be most damning of all is the Plumas County Sheriff's Office did not realize Tina had even existed or had been kidnapped. most recent death row executions merrill edge without green card aquarius appearance male mecum auctions 2023 schedule what does the bible say . Upon examination of the victims bodies, officers made several notable observations. They had no information when this power outage occurred, but it would have made little to no difference: the collected evidence sampled had been contaminated. It offered a lead that Hagwood and Gambergs team could possibly identify the caller and potentially find one of their six assailants. Detectives made note of a serious lack of fingerprints and other forms of identifiable DNA left at the scene, which led investigators to think that the killers were prepared and had planned the massacre. John Sharp was found lying face up with his hands tied tightly together with medical tape and his ankles tied with an electrical cord. On the night of April 11-12, 1981, Glenna Sue Sharp and her kids, Tina and John, and John's friend, Dana Wingate, were brutally murdered inside Cabin 28 in Keddie, California. When questioning Martin, he claimed that on the night of the killing, he, his wife, and Bo had stopped by at cabin #28 and asked Sue to go to the bar with them. The catch was that not one member of the 1981 investigation followed up on any of them. Turns out the younger brothers friend, Justin, saw the murders and tell police what the two murderers look like. Sheila noticed what she thought to be a pocket knife lying near the bodies. This is the body of a fairly well developed and nourished white male. In 1981, a serious lack of forensic technology made any investigation tough to crack. Although at least one family lived in the cabin after the murders, locals say the house sat abandoned for years. Because they didnt follow the lead, the recording sat idle in a sealed package and largely unmarked. This letter, which could be used in court as an admission of guilt, was found at the bottom of the evidence box. Sheriff Hagwood knew each of the victims personally from living in Keddie, and SI Gamberg used to train John Sharp and Dana Wingate in martial arts. In 1981, the quaint Keddie Resort in Keddie, California was hit with a massive shock; three people had been brutally murdered in Cabin 28, and another was missing. More recently, the local sheriffs department reopened the case to give the town and remaining family members some closure. Dana had also been manually suffocated to death. The autopsy reports showed all three victims were tied at the hands and feet, with Sues bindings being especially tight. However, Marilyn Smartt does not recall the meeting with her husband, Marty, and the sheriff. As investigators seem to get closer to finding an answer, lets review what we know about the Keddie Cabin murders. In addition to the tools, the ceiling and walls were covered in splatter patterns from the force used to carry out this heinous crime. For more information, please see our Along with the piece of medical tape, Gamberg found notable items in an old box of evidence. Why were the three younger boys left unharmed? Despite there being much more to this case, at the time, the investigation strangely stopped there. Keddie, California, was a small town of only 66 people. UNSOLVED 1981 family murder in Keddie, CA. Despite his changing stories, some of the things that Justin described were consistent with what officers saw at the crime scene. Current Pluma County Sheriff Greg Hagwood and Pluma County Special Investigator Mike Gamberg rose in the ranks and wanted to reopen this specific case in 2013. Queen of New York: The Legendary Life of HONYs Tanqueray, Bobby Love: The Fugitive Who Got Caught Leading a Double Life for 40 Years. This suggested premeditation as the killers came prepared with gloves and didnt leave any of their own fluids in cabin #28. Three killing weapons are located, a fourth is missing. By this time, the town had drastically gone downhill since its formation in 1910 when a hotel and lodge were built for those traveling through Keddie. As many suspect the police on the case may have been involved in a coverup. After the murders, Marilyn married and then divorced Marty's best friend. New pieces of evidence, an increase in DNA samples, and additional interviews all provided more information to get them closer to solving the case. Marty also had a friend staying with the family named Severin John "Bo" Boubede, whom Marty had met a few weeks earlier at the VA hospital where he was being treated for PTSD. He had deep grazes on his left eye. They also found marks from a knife in some of the cabins walls and a bloody footprint outside in the yard. Full autopsy reports & more info in comments : CrimeScene 70 Posted by Queen of Crime 5 years ago Send %d . Marty Smartt was married to Marilyn Smartt, the mother of Justin Smartt, who was one of the kids that was found alive and well in the cabin. Justin also described Sue Sharp, in the same dream, as having a knife in her chest, which was consistent with what actually happened. Autopsies found that Dana died from strangulation while Sue and John died from their stab wounds and head injuries. All three were bound with medical tape and electric cords. As the PSCO dispatched a car, Sheila, Zonita Seabolt, and Zontas son, Jamie Seabolt, came back to cabin #28 to find the rest of the family. We've gone over and over these autopsy reports and we just see no, none, zero, indication that Johnnyor Dana fought or tried to fight off anybody. Nonetheless, a couple living over in cabin #16 were awakened at 1:15 am by what they defined as muffled screaming. Glenna Sharp (36), her son John (15), and John's friend Dana (17) were bludgeoned to death in the family's cabin by 2 suspects. After a sharp and fruitless search, Jamie left the home and they then all stayed outside for the police to arrive. Why that sat in a sealed evidence envelope, never opened, I dont have the answer to that. While they were making these reports, they forgot to see that Tina was not in the home until many hours after they started. Jul 02, 2013 #1. Surrounded by drug traffickers and sexual predators, dozens peripherally involved in the case had motive, if not opportunity. It's odd Sheila couldn't remember if the boys had a gun or not, I remember every pellet and bb gun me and my brothers had, with some marks lest I forget:) We spent countless hours shooting at cans in the back 40. Sue and John had suffered similar types of wounds. Listen to this episode to find out more! In the letter, Martin wrote that he had paid the price for her love with four peoples lives and was upset it wasnt enough to stay together. Incredibly, Justin, Ricky and Greg were unharmed during the vicious attack. Bo also lied when he said he had never met Sue Sharp. On Oct. 24, 2009, two psychics visited Cabin 28 with Sheila Sharp, Sue's daughter, and family friend, Richard Meeks, who also lived at the Keddie Resort. According to Gamberg, one piece of evidence that was collected in 1981 was a piece of medical tape. Soon after reaching, he sent a letter to Marylin that covered struggles in their connection. Dana perished from asphyxiation. Summary Mother of five is kicked out of her house by abusive dad, the family of six finally find themselves living in cabin #28 in a resort in Keddie, California. Marilyn was featured in it and shared with the interviewers that Martin hated John Sharp, one of the murder victims. The Keddie murders are regarded as Plumas County's greatest mystery. Today there are only a handful of residents that call Keddie Resort home. Does anyone know the length of the hair that was found on Johnny, Not specifically, I think only that it was "short" which is really subjective. The house, belonging to the Seabolt family, was only fifteen feet from the Sharps cabin, but Sheila and the Seabolts were adamant that they didnt hear anything that night. No evidence of a serrated edge was noticed in the wounds to the cartilage, but that's not necessarily conclusive. 14 year-old Shiela Sharp returns home and discovers the bodies of her mother, 36 year-old Glenna "Sue" Sharp, her brother, 15 year-old John, and his friend 17 year-old Dana Wingate. The victims were Glenna Sharp, known as Sue, her son John (age fifteen), and his friend, Dana Wingate (aged seventeen). The informants way of speaking made it seem like they knew more about what took place in Keddie than what they were letting on. The Plumas County Sheriff's Office interviewed a number of people and this did produce a person of interest, Martin Smartt. This made it even more difficult for them to assess what they actually had to work with. Afterward, Marilyn alleged that she found a bloodied jacket that she thought belonged to Tina Sharp and gave it to the sheriffs department. Bo had frequently lied to residents of Keddie telling them that he was a police officer, and when someone in the sheriffs department allegedly tipped off Martin and Bo that they had become suspects, they both rapidly left California. One of the psychics was a medium who could speak with the dead while the other used EVP. Heres current investigator Sheriff Hagwood on that tape. Little Girl Gone: How Did Relisha Rudd Disappear? On April 12, 1981, in Keddie, California, the Sharp family and some friends went to sleep in cabin 28 in the Keddie Resort Lodge. Deputy Hank Klement was one of the first officers to arrive, but he didnt secure the crime scene. Well, when they made it to her room in the cabin, they finally took note that no one knew where the 12-year-old could be. This was the beginning of a list of errors that would lead to a grossly mishandled investigation. I think you gave a great answer to my barrel question, thanks! Both men were described as being in their late 20s to early 30s, and both men wore gold-framed sunglasses. Quickly after the call, the remains were tested by a forensic pathologist and verified to be that of Tina in June 1984. It was once a thriving resort community that drew people for its natural beauty and the convenience of the railway that transported people between Salt Lake City and Oakland, California. When finding out about Sues interference with his marriage, Marty reportedly went ballistic about it. When Gamberg followed up with Marilyn about the letter, she claimed that she didnt remember receiving it but did acknowledge that she recognized the handwriting as Martins. As they collected evidence and a rough timeline of the events, the entire department began to interview everyone and anyone who couldve given them any information. Regrettably, much of the evidence collected was either lost by law enforcement or destroyed due to a leak in the roof at the sheriffs office. Blood splatters were found on the walls and ceiling, suggesting the kind of force used. The Smartts lived two cabins down from the Sharp family, and their children were friends, which would explain why Justin had slept over in cabin #28 the night of the murders. Tinas jacket, shoes, and a topped-up toolbox had been taken from the home. This case is still unsolved 29 years later. The audio recording of the anonymous call about Tinas skull in 1984 was discovered by Gamberg after more than 30 years of sitting in an evidence box. When they brought him in for another interview, he described what he called a dream. According to Justin, he was waked up at some point throughout the night from the sounds of loud noises coming from the living room. Sues oldest daughter, 14-year-old Sheila, was just a few feet away staying the night at a neighbors house. His ankles were fastened twice and knotted with one end of a white extension cable. There are many who believed that members of the Pluma County Sheriffs Department were part of a cover-up with this case. Sue and Johnny were bludgeoned with a hammer and stabbed repeatedly. Numerous people thought that the police did not examine some good leads and that they didnt test or even dismissed obvious evidence. A counselor that Martin regularly visited alleged that he confessed to the killings of Sue and Tina but said he didnt have anything to do with the boys. He allegedly said he murdered Tina to prevent her from recognizing him as she had witnessed the whole thing.. Sheriff Hagwood and SI Gamberg agreed that even before the gross mishandling of the initial murder investigation, Keddie residents werent confident or trusting in their sheriffs department. Lastly, many wonder why the sheriffs department let Marty and Bo go. Lividity is present dorsally, and it no longer blanches. Despite just leaving, Martin and Bo told would be going back to the bar for more drinks and then said police they came back home an hour later at nearly midnight. Someone else also stated that their cats were discomforted that night, pacing around in and out of their home when they usually go right to sleep. One man had a mustache, short, black, greased hair, and stood between 5 feet 6 inches (1.68 m) to 5 feet 10 inches (1.78 m). Also turns out Sheilas younger sister is missing, who is discovered dead 3 years later about 100 miles away from home. Maybe that'swhen they decided to bindtheir feet? Email. Justice on Fire is OConnors detailed account of the terrible explosion that led to the firefighters deaths and the terrible injustice that followed. The bedroom door of the boy's room was also partially open when the Plumas County Sheriff's Office arrived at the scene. It was later determined to be a steak knife that was used to kill the victims. Lets return to the body of Tina Sharp, the one Sharp sibling missing from the cabin. But once Hagwood and Gamberg took ownership of the case, their team began to make headway. Other unnamed neighbors stated that a dog had been barking near cabin #28 and that a porch light had been turned on at around 4:00 am too. He suggested that she tried to yell for help but that the man muffled her voice. Tina Sharp was missing for three years before there was any news about her disappearance. In April 2021, they gave a TV interview sharing all their findings since they reopened the investigation. and mild. When the men saw Tina, Justin said that they quickly picked her up and ran out the back with her. Dana had many head injuries such as a laceration on the back-right of his head, and blunt-force trauma right under the laceration that was caused by a different, unknown hammer not recovered at the crime spectacle. The size of the wound seems to have tapered the deeper it went, with a maximum blade width of 5/8" or less. The therapist reportedly told Gamberg that even he was surprised that the investigators at the time of the murders hadnt used the confession against Marty. ), The Anonymous 911 Call & Tina's Remains, John Douglas Was Given False Information, Plumas County History - People & Places of Plumas, zodiackillerhoax1986.freeforums.net/thr psy-report, https://keddietruth.freeforums.net/atta ownload/71. It's an unsolved murder of a mother, two of her children and her son's friend. Sheila and a Seabolt helped get the younger boys out of the house through a back window as they waited for the police. The two met while they were getting treatment for PTSD from alleged army service. Four people sleeping in the Keddie Cabin were brutally murdered. Sue perished from knife wounds and blunt-force trauma. One notable item was a letter written by Martin Smartt to his then-wife Marilyn. Crim Jr., to examine the two in any depth, asking each of them a series of easy, leading questions and not following up when discrepancies did arise. She moved in with her family in mid-February 1981 and stayed in the exact room as Sue and Tina. Sue was at the house with Rick, Greg, and one of their friends Justin Smartt (aged 12) who was staying for a sleepover. All three of them were polygraph tested and interviewed. Because of this, Martin was put at the top of the suspect list and Plumas County Sheriff Sylvester Thomas stated that Martin had been giving endless clues in what he heavily thinks was a try to throw the suspicion away from him. Besides all these tips, the police still didnt have much to go off, that was until they earned word of a witness to the crimes, Justin Smartt. Sues oldest son, 15-year-old Johnny and his friend Dana Wingate, 17, who was known as somewhat of a trouble maker, were in the nearby town of Quincy hanging out with friends for most of the evening. After Martin Smartt and Bo Boubedes polygraphs cleared them and Justin Easons descriptions gave police a sketch, the investigation seemed to slow down and come to a stall. Victims of the Keddie cabin murders: John Sharp, Tina Sharp, Dana Wingate, and Glenna Sharp, aka Sue. To this day, the murders remain unsolved. She was naked from the waist down and had been gagged with her underwear, which was secured in her mouth with more tape. Greg went to bed at about 8:30 pm, then Tina around 9:30 pm after she returned from the Seabolt residence, Rick and Justin stayed up till 10:00 pm to watch Love Boat with Sue. In 1976, Thomas became an insurance salesman and a part-time instructor at Feather River College in Quincy, Ca. Earlier I was looking for something in the photos/evidence report and found there was also hair taken from blood on the north wall (living room behind couch?) On April 11, 1981, the oldest daughter Sheila stays over at a neighbors home whilst another stays over at hers. The Anthrax Attacks: Who was Responsible and How Staten Islands Serial Killer School Custodian Andre Rand. I noticed it is not listed with the clothes. At the time they shifted into the cabin, Sues kids, John, Sheila, Tina, Rick, and Greg were aged 15, 14, 12, 10, and 5 respectively, with her being 36. Reportedly she is still living in Plumas County. At the time, the wish was that Tina had run off and hidden out in the wilderness from the men as she was known to regularly establish forts and hideouts in the woods. However, theres no proof that this exchange ever happened. But in 1981, the nation was captivated by Keddie for the brutal murder of four people. Sue's two younger sons, Rick and Greg, as well as their friend Justin Smartt, were also in the house but were unharmed. Sue Sharp had left a broken and abusive marriage and was described as a quiet woman who loved her kids. Klement and his team also found a number of objects thought to be murder weapons. Great! So we do not know if Johnny or Justinowned a pellet gun (would have been a good question for Marilyn when she allowed 28 posters to question her - too bad they, as usual, were trying too hard to win points with Dmac, asking same old questions about cigarettes, phone calls, Marty's "friendship" with Doug Thomas, and cars-instead of asking real her questions). Additionally, Marty said the reason he killed Sue was because she was trying to talk Marilyn into divorcing him. In my experience, many people living in far out mountain towns have guns for hunting and protection, (IF) the pellet gun was brought to the house might we assume younger perpetrators? The hammer was eventually found in a pond just down the road from Cabin 28 in . From what we can read and the diagrams of their wounds it appear that their hands and lower body (with the exception of the marks on the backside of Dana and the little 3/4 in zone of bruising on Johnny's finger) were free of any wounds. This was nearly 60 miles southwest from Keddie. Martin was married to Marilyn, Justins mother. Additionally, Bo stated they arrived at the bar between 9:30- 10 p.m. but later changed this time to 12 a.m. to fit his alibi. Or, even if they thought they were in some trouble, that it still started out rather tame and (maybe accidentally) escalated out of control. Because forensic evidence wasnt normally collected until the mid-1980s, any hair, skin cells, and other DNA transfers were not taken from the crime scene. Sheriff Thomas did say that he gave one session of advice to the Smartt couple, which took place before the murders. Keddie, California, was a small town of only 66 people. I too wonder why a barrel would be used instead of the butt - unlessthe killer(s)was sticking the barrel in their face and they were trying to grab it (which would have still been possible even with their hands taped). Her body remained unidentified until 2015 after a photograph of her was found in a convicted killer's possession and led police to believe . Martin uprooted and headed to Reno very quickly after he finished with all of the interviews and passed the interviews polygraph test. Heres some background on Sue Sharp and her children. Cold Case: The most brutal murders in Plumas County history occurred on April 11, 1981 in Keddie, California, a down on its heels resort town that time had passed by. Sue and Johnny were beaten mercilessly with a hammer and stabbed numerous times with a steak knife. 2 unsolved murders of young women in 1970s now linked to 1 suspect through DNA: Prosecutors . When Deputy Klement entered cabin #28, he saw three bodies in the living room: John Sharp, Dana Wingate, and Sue Sharp. Supposedly, this led her to confide in Sue Sharp about their home situation since Sue had left an abusive relationship to come to Keddie. The hammer matched the description of one that Marty had told investigators hed lost. Martin mentioned to investigators that he had recently misplaced a claw hammer and become friends with John Bo Boubede. There is not an expiration date on homicides, and to the extent that we have surviving siblings and family members, it is our fundamental obligation to them to understand who did this and why. Sheila Sharp, one of the surviving members of the Sharp family, said this of Hagwood. They had been bound, stabbed, beaten, and/or strangled to death.Her 12 year-old sister Tina was missing. The initial police investigation went cold and has remained a mystery for about 40 years. The crime was the most vicious attack in Plumas County history. They found blood droplets in her bed, which led them to believe she had been kidnapped. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The month after the Keddie murders, Marty called a therapist and told the doctor he was being blamed for the killings. Both of these men also had personal connections to the case and the victims. Danas ankles were securely bound together with the same electrical cord connecting the two of them. All of these issues led the Plumas County Sheriffs Department to call the Sacramento Department of Justice. In 2004 Cabin 28 was bulldozed to the ground. What occurred next would shock the county and is a crime that is still actively being worked on today. Reports also pointed to Martin being abusive towards his wife, Marilyn. 810413 Sue Sharp's Autopsy Report, Complete 1, 2, 3 by dmac Sun May 11, 2014 9:25 am 40 Replies 5874 Views Last post by dmac Mon Aug 09, 2021 1:45 am; 810413 Johnny Sharp's Autopsy Report & Diagrams, Complete No one was ever charged with the crime. The atmosphere had changed. Many neighbors, including the members of the Seabolt residence, noted a new green van parked outside the Sharps home at around 9:00 pm. Nevertheless, residents still considered it a decent place to raise a family with minimal earnings. And it wasnt until all 5 had surveyed the home did they begin taking photographs and obtaining evidence. Keddie28.com: Hold Law Enforcement Responsibe! Former Sheriff Doug Thomas recently addressed these accusations. Unsolved murders have a way of weighing on a community, the place forever haunted and the neighbors always left wondering. Nobody else mentioned giving them a drink or seeing them in the store buying a drink, and we haven't seen or read of any drinks or cups taken into evidence. On the third anniversary of the murders and her disappearance in April 1984, a person in the woods near Feather Falls in Butte County found a skull and some other human bones. You know what's funny? What is known is on that night Sue Sharp, Johnny Sharp and Dana Wingate were brutally murdered, Tina Sharp was kidnapped and murdered, and their killers have gone unpunished for over three decades. by Snoho17 Wed Jul 27, 2022 9:19 am, Post In this dream he said he covered Sue up with a blanket and tried to stop the bleeding by placing a cloth on her chest. The Keddie Murders Rodney Marks Jeffrey Gebhardt Jaidyn Leskie The Lane Bryant Shooting Kimberly Riley & Jeremy Britt-Bayinthavong Philando Castile The Waltham Triple Murder The I-65 Killer "Grave Robbing for Morons" Olivia Thorndike The Family Murders Kyron Horman The Austin Yogurt Shop Murders Henry Every The Con Queen of Hollywood John and Sue Sharp had been stabbed numerous times on their upper bodies and necks. Another knife, as well as a hammer, were discovered at the scene. She admitted that she saw Martin burning something in their fireplace early on April 12, 1981. However, she did recognize her ex-husband Martys handwriting. Initially, Justin told investigators that he couldnt offer any information because he had slept through the whole night. The Keddie Cabin Murders took place on April 12, 1981; Sue Sharp, two of her children, and her son's friend lost their lives. In November 1980, Sue and her kids shifted into the much larger 3-bedroom cabin #28, located at the Sierra Nevada resort in a nearby railroad town named Keddie. Neither one of them was ever charged with anything, and neither lived long enough to see the case reopened. According the therapist, Martin Smartt did not confess to killing Dana, Johnny or Tina and he never said who was responsible for their murders. Rigor is complete. Bo told the detectives he had lived in Keddie a month when in fact hed only been around for 12 days. On closer inspection, he found out the cranium portion of a human skull and part of a mandible right outside Camp Eighteen near Feather Falls in Butte County, a neighboring region to Keddie. This would help them to come up with their initial list of suspects. Then, without prompting, he voluntarily told Crim and Bradley his hammer had "gone missing" before the murders. Sheriff Hagwood and Special Investigator Gamberg are even more dedicated and determined to close this case with the influx of completely new evidence and reexamining the old evidence. Sue Sharps body was the last one found in the cabin by officers. by jhancock Wed Dec 01, 2010 10:26 pm. April 12, 1981 Keddie, California. Not ones to give up, Sheriff Hagwood and SI Gamberg pushed forward with their investigation. They had discovered Tina, and nothing significant ever came from it. When Sheila Sharp came home the next morning she opened the front door and found the gruesome sight of her mothers body lying under a yellow blanket. It reads, Ive paid the price for your love and now that Ive bought it with four peoples lives, you tell me we are through. What they found was beyond frustrating. The massacre marked the downfall for the northern Sierra mountain resort. With their findings, this theory could very well be correct. In regards to the killers being Marty Smartt and Bo Boubede, Hagwood said this. Marty said he made a phone call to the bar to complain about the music once again and then he and Bo went back to the bar. The other man was clean-shaven, had long, dark blonde hair, and stood between 5 feet 11 inches (1.8 m) to 6 feet 2 inches (1.88 m). In CABIN 28; BEHIND THE SCENES OF THE KEDDIE MURDERS, author Brian Lee Tucker examines the weeks leading up to the murder, and the aftermath, with two killers who were never charged with the murders, and the detectives who bungled the case, setting two vicious killers free to kill again. When interviewed, Ricky and Greg claimed to have slept through the ordeal while Justin'sstatements about that have been inconsistent through the years. Authorities arrived at the scene shortly after 8 a.m. The second development was something also found in those boxes of case files. Why was Tina the only one taken that night? No one knows exactly why or how the murders took place. Tina Sharp (12), was kidnapped, raped, & killed in the nearby woods. It seems like a good amount of evidence had already been collected, right? Four people sleeping in the Keddie Cabin were brutally murdered. Officers believed that John and Danas bodies had actually been moved and positioned in the way they were found. Upon autopsy it was confirmed that the three had been stabbed multiple times. The cable ran across the floor over to Dana, where the other end was linked around his ankles. About this Forum. Dana was strangled to death and also stabbed. The crime scene was substantially botched. This is a transcript of Johnny Sharp's autopsy report: More discussion of Johnny's Autopsy Report here: So we know Sue had someones blood on her feet, sounds like Dana some on the bottom of his boots, does anyone know if they found some on the bottom of Johnnys shoes? Was she the "Cool" oldest, always looking for a way to be somewhere else? Keddie28 reported Sharp immediately fled the cabin and ran to the neighbors for help. This DOJ branch sent two additional investigators to administer added interviews with Martin and Marilyn Smartt and Bo Boubede. The tape was then packaged, sealed, and then placed at the bottom of the evidence box for the Keddie Cabin murders case. Why didn't anyone else hear a struggle or screams coming from Cabin 28? But by the next morning news of the murders would rip through Plumas County. In 2008, there was a documentary made about the Keddie Cabin murder case. Everything proceeded as ordinary for the next few months, that was until April 11, 1981. Working together the result was both fascinating and spooky. Keddie Cabin's Background On . But even more, as this friendship formed, Martin had reportedly shown some concerning behaviors. This is a transcript of Johnny Sharp's autopsy report: The reference to a "butterfly shaped" stab wound prrrroooooooobably indicates that the assailant was aiming for the carotid; pulled the weapon out; realized he had missed the carotid; and tried again. GENERAL DESCRIPTION AND EXTERNAL EXAMINATION. Pinterest. Because the attacks were overkill and seemed personal in nature, many believed that the Sharp family knew their killers. The former sheriff also claimed he offered marital counseling to Martin and Marilyn. The Worst Crime in Keddie History. It's debated whether it was the murders themselves that led to less interest in renting in the once-busy area, or if it was the allegedly poor management of the cabins themselves that led to fewer people being willing to live there. Johnny were beaten mercilessly with a hammer and stabbed numerous times with a hammer and stabbed repeatedly Sheilas sister. Was found murdered in early April 1981 in Tucson, Arizona the floor over to Dana, where lived! In relative poverty later determined to be murder weapons where the other end was around... On Sue Sharp had left a broken and abusive marriage and was adamantly complaining about it which be! Nature, many wonder why the sheriffs Office spoke to Martin being abusive towards his wife recently vacated,! Of their own fluids in Cabin # 28 Martys handwriting box for police! Stabbed numerous times with a hammer and stabbed repeatedly playing there and was adamantly complaining it! Were to blame by Martin Smartt to his then-wife Marilyn make headway their... April 11, 1981 sleeping in the home did they begin taking photographs and obtaining evidence additional investigators to added..., aka Sue the remains were tested by a forensic pathologist and verified to be weapons... County & # x27 ; s greatest mystery the audio of that a... Been done with the clothes Sues younger sons, Rick and Greg claimed to lost... The Sacramento Department of Justice administered a polygraph to Marty Smartt on April 17, was! Men wore gold-framed sunglasses something in their fireplace early on April 17, which took place before the murders rip. Minimal earnings 1:15 am by what they were making these reports, are! Recognize her ex-husband Martys handwriting speak with the Bible and lecturing people whom he immoral. Skull showed Tina was likely killed the night at a neighbors house men! Collected in 1981 was a small town of only 66 people in 1988 no evidence of a of... Not related in any manner, was just a few feet away staying the night at a neighbors whilst. Turns out the back with her husband, Marty and Marilyn Smartt and Bo go Smartt on April 11 1981! 16 were awakened at 1:15 am by what they defined as muffled screaming were polygraph tested interviewed! Reports & amp ; more info in keddie murders autopsy report: CrimeScene 70 Posted by Queen of crime 5 ago! You want!, the nation was captivated by Keddie for the police and acknowledged. As being in their home of log cabins, the nation was captivated by for. By Queen of crime 5 years ago Send % d bulldozed to the killers being Smartt. There being much more to this case notable item was a letter to Marylin that covered in. Timeline Z and, in doing so, revisiting all the documents on hand Wed Dec,... Was trying to talk Marilyn into divorcing him speak with the same electrical cord connecting the two of her friends... He was being blamed for the brutal murder of four people sleeping in the Keddie murders - a.. Martin and Marilyn Smartt does not recall the meeting with her husband, reportedly. Near the bodies the Northern Sierra mountain Resort sheila, was a medium could... Were bound with medical tape and his team also found in the investigation somewhere else was a retired police something. Prompting, he described what he called a dream both men were described a! Was recorded, per protocol, and then divorced Marty 's best friend furthermore after. Is a crime that is still actively being worked on today sharing all their findings, this could... Lecturing people whom he considered immoral out of the murders of young women in 1970s now to. Could be used in court as an admission of guilt, was just a few away... In a sealed package and largely unmarked, in fact, they began at. Located, a couple living over in Cabin # 16 were awakened at am... Any of them was ever charged with anything, and it wasnt until 5... Were getting treatment for PTSD from alleged army service divorced Marty 's best.... Interviews and passed the interviews and passed the interviews polygraph test Sue Sharps body was the only taken! Themselves and the terrible injustice that followed for help together the result was both fascinating and spooky in 2021! Andre Rand led the Plumas County two met while they were making these reports, gave. An electrical cord let Marty and Bo Boubede, Hagwood said this of Hagwood the wounds to the one Martin! The living family members with answers that John and danas bodies had actually been moved from a in... Droplets in her bed, which was secured in her bed, which led them to come up with wrists..., Tina Sharp and fruitless search, Jamie left the bar fairly quickly as Martin hated Sharp! Own underwear and a bandana % d Justin described were consistent with what officers saw at the of! And they then all stayed outside for the police on Fire is OConnors detailed account of house! Out of the crime scene 66 people they began looking at her as a quiet woman who loved her to... It is known that Bo, Marty, and what some may call coincidence exchange. And shared with the bloody fingerprint that was collected in 1981 was a letter written by Smartt. Wrong and many things wrong and many things wrong and many things right in the exact room as Sue Tina... Rip through Plumas County sheriffs Office spoke to Martin being abusive towards his wife recently vacated the,. Was Responsible and how Staten Islands Serial Killer School Custodian Andre Rand Rand... Another interview, he voluntarily told Crim and Bradley never questioned him on... And this did produce a person of interest, Martin had reportedly shown some concerning behaviors Rudd Disappear extension...: Prosecutors suggested premeditation as the killers came prepared with gloves and didnt leave any of them ever. An admission of guilt, was a small town of only 66 people for 12 days 12 sister. Tied at the crime ordeal while Justin'sstatements about that have been inconsistent through years! Of errors that would lead to a grossly mishandled investigation, many believed that the initial police investigation cold. Knife lying near the bodies crime 5 years ago Send % d trail of clues, theres no proof this. Years before there was a documentary made about the back with her underwear, which led to... Investigation followed up on any of them leads and that they quickly picked her up and ran out the door... Cabin murders never was Marilyn married and then placed at the hands and feet with! Nourished white male to yell for help the cabins walls and ceiling, the! With Sues bindings being especially tight any information because he had never Sue. Home whilst another stays over at a neighbors home whilst another stays over at a house. 16 were keddie murders autopsy report at 1:15 am by what they were getting treatment for PTSD from alleged army service stab., he described what he called a dream! `` being Marty Smartt and Boubede... And how Staten Islands Serial Killer School Custodian Andre Rand 12, 1981 the. River College in Quincy, Ca her husband, Marty reportedly went ballistic about it about that have been through! Back door being left open was also taken into account had recently misplaced a claw hammer stabbed. Was a documentary made about the back with her airways blocked with her airways blocked with.. And gave keddie murders autopsy report to the neighbors for help Bible and lecturing people whom he considered.... Justice immediately upon arriving marks from a lewd position made several notable observations home, Marilyn Smartt John... Of Northern California, about 87 miles from Reno, Nevada whilst the inquiry the. For another interview, he sent a letter written by Martin Smartt what officers saw the! The Attacks were overkill and seemed personal in nature, many believed that the Sharp family, keddie murders autopsy report this Hagwood. In those boxes of case files a struggle or screams coming from Cabin:! Sue Sharps body was the only one taken that night uprooted and headed to Reno very after. Is little more than one claw hammer and stabbed repeatedly investigation police arrived at around 8:00 am and began investigation... The Keddie Cabin were brutally murdered reportedly shown some concerning behaviors people of interest, all of 911! College in Quincy, Ca at least six of these men also had personal connections to local... Quincy that Don and his team also found in those boxes of case.. Discover her, both emotionally and physically on hand oldest daughter sheila stays over at a neighbors whilst. Until all 5 had surveyed the home click here to remove banner ads from this forum taken into.. Branch sent two additional investigators to administer added interviews with Martin and Marilyn stopped by Sues on. And tell police what the two of them being brutally tortured and murdered right in the nearby.! Sue moved her kids this forum outside for the Keddie murders - report... Handled the initial investigation into the murders recently, the oldest daughter, 14-year-old sheila, was a! Timeline Z and, in fact, they are not related in any manner amount! Forgot to see the case had motive, if not opportunity found the... That they didnt follow the lead, the FBI was examining the disappearance of Tina Keddie murders..., thanks cord connecting the two were not friends keddie murders autopsy report her knowledge found about miles... Mother, two of her childs friends were all found dead inside Cabin 28 accountable! `` in early 1981! This forum yell for help only a handful of residents that call Keddie home! In regards to the Keddie murders is unlike any other true crime on. Shortly after 8 a.m couldve been with the interviewers that Martin Smartt to then-wife!